Eileen Reavey leads Rank the Vote, a national organization supporting citizen movements for ranked choice voting and other election reforms. She joined Caitlin Bagot Davis on By the Way, Conversations with Portland ahead of the November 3 general election. Excerpts, edited for length.
Caitlin: Do you have any voting rituals these days?
Eileen: I typically do it at home at my kitchen table and have my voter guide out. I want to do my due diligence and research every candidate and see what their opinion is.
Caitlin: What isn't working for communities that requires better systems?
Eileen: I'd say it's unique to each community. I'm not here with the organization I work for to tell you this is the solution that's going to solve all your problems. I'm going to say, "You tell me what's not working." It's: "Let's figure out what is the problem." And often it is that elected officials do not feel beholden to the people voting for them.
Caitlin: How do these grassroots groups get started?
Eileen: You just need one person to get excited about it and bring other people along.
Caitlin: Can you tell me a story about that?
Eileen: Our campaign in Longmont right now, for example, we've got a really motivated college student, Dylan Rankin, who said, "I want to see this change happen." And has been a big part of bringing it through his community, and now it's on the ballot.
Caitlin: I wonder what you do with [...] misinformation about rank choice voting: that it's new, that it's untried, that it's mysterious.
Eileen: I hope that a little information goes a long way of meeting people where they are. I understand that you haven't heard of it before, but it is used in two states and over 50 cities and counties in the United States. It's been used in Australia and Ireland for over a hundred years. It is tested. It's tried and true. What's your next question? How can I make you more comfortable with this idea?
Caitlin: Do you see rank choice voting being used to surface diversity of opinions in a governing body?
Eileen: Yeah, absolutely. We previously had, in 100 years, two city councilors that lived east of 82nd. Now, because we have a multi-winner district system, we have three members from that district. Right now, six of our city councilors are women, 50%. Right now we have our two first-ever Asian-American council members elected. That's not a fluke. It's because we went to a system that is more representative.
Caitlin: By my math, six or seven of the seats on city council should be held by what I would call a more progressive candidate, looking at the district-by-district makeup of voters: how they voted on guns, abortion, local and state taxes, who they picked in the last [2022] governor's race. If you run the campaign math on a more moderate candidate in the city as a city-wide race like our old election system, their odds of success were quite weak. Another way of saying it is a moderate has a better chance of being elected in proportional rank choice voting than they used to in the city of Portland, unless they won a primary.
What we've heard from advocates in Portland is that it's so great because all these progressives got elected. Why don't we hear more people talking about the reality that there are a bunch of moderates sitting in city council who would not have been elected in our winner-take-all election system?
Eileen: I think that part of why you don't hear about that, is the change of having a majority of progressives of course gets a lot of media attention. But naturally, if that's a majority of the city, there are also a lot of advocacy groups that are very happy about that fact and are going out and talking about it and touting that as a big win for them. I would say on the moderate side, there is less alignment in terms of the community groups that might be going out and carrying that message on their behalf. And so it's just not getting out there.
Caitlin: Where [did] this value around representation started for you?
Eileen: For me, a part of it honestly comes from the fact I have very different political beliefs from my parents. I just really appreciated that for my parents, it wasn't about trying to get me to agree with them. If I could articulate my opinion and my stance and why I felt about something, that was the outcome that they wanted, even if I didn't agree with them.
One of the first electoral issues I worked on was the National Popular Vote Compact, with the idea that every vote for president should be equal. I would often cite my mom, who at that time had been a voter for over four decades and, because of the state she had lived in, had never felt like her vote for president mattered. And so I want everyone to feel like their vote matters. It does. It should.
Caitlin: One of the things I've seen in the democracy reform space is deep conflict about "perfect" reforms. How do you live with this?
Eileen: I honestly think some of it comes from a scarcity mindset. The electoral reform movement is horrifically underfunded. We have to get it perfect the first time. I would rather have a reform pass that benefits people and they have better representation rather than holding out for something that I think might give, let's say, 10% more representation, but it's going to cost $5 more million and take 10 extra years.
Caitlin: I'm wondering what your Bull Run is. What is the thing, big or small, that you believe we can build now for future generations?
Eileen: If I were to put it in the smallest possible terms, it would be a movement. I truly believe in the power of everyday people to make change and to stand up and say, I don't like how this is going, or this thing is wrong, and I'm going to be a part of changing it for the better.
Big changes are possible. If you had told someone in 1995 that there was a way to change the way we elect the president without a constitutional amendment, they would have said that's ridiculous. Here we are, 31 years after that, and we are on the cusp of changing it. I hope it just sparks a moment of joy and excitement that people really know that they can make change.
Listen to the full hour. Eileen and Caitlin go much further: what Ireland's century of ranked voting can teach Portland, why two Scottish cities using the same system elect very different councils, where "fringe" ends and representation begins, and a call-a-friend detour into turning Portland's airport taxi drivers into tour guides. [Link to episode]